Subject: Corba interfaces and GPL freedom
From: "Iain Barker" <iain@member.fsf.org>
Date: Sat, 13 Sep 2003 14:30:18 -0400

I am concerned whether a Corba interface can be used by non-free software to
circumvent the freedoms and requirements of the GPL license. I realise "mere
aggregation" vs the definition of a copyright derived work is a complex
scenario, so I will try to keep my posting generic.

A proprietary vendor could create non-free software that functionally would
amount to a derived work, without actually making a derived work within the
meaning of copyright law. Would this break the spirit of the GPL while
complying with its terms, hence not be enforcable under copyright law?

I have seen the Corba 'serverizing' analogy discussed on this list, and have
looked around the FSF website for clarification but I don't see any position
statement from FSF addressing this issue. The nearest entry in the FSF
GPL-FAQ is the "pipes and sockets" definition, which suggests this form of
abstract inter-process communication is an acceptable mechanism for GPL
software to interwork with non-free modules.

I've also read the earlier icense-discuss postings of Mr Perens, Mr Stallman
and others regarding the use of Corba in this manner. The absence of a
position from the FSF appears to be potentially damaging the GPL community,
which risks losing freedom to the proponents of non-free software.


Here is an example of Corba 'serverizing':

A GPL application is modified by a vendor of non-free software, who adds a
Corba server API to the application. The vendor releases the source code to
the GPL application and modifications per the GPL terms.

The vendor then creates a non-free Corba client application which uses that
API but incorporates none of the GPL code. The source code to the client
application is not released by the vendor. Non-free applications could also
be used as Corba servers to a GPL client application in the same manner.

Essentially the freedom of the GPL codebase is reduced either way around.


-- 
Iain W. Barker, FSF member 336. iain@member.fsf.org
  .--- .-..-..-..-.    .-.  .-..-..-..-..-..-..-.
  ||_-.| .` || || | // | |_ | || .` || || | >  <
  `---'`-'`-'`----'    `---'`-'`-'`-'`----''-'`-`
   Life's too short to compute on anything else
--
license-discuss archive is at http://crynwr.com/cgi-bin/ezmlm-cgi?3