Subject: Re: Creative Commons style open source licenses?
From: Allison Randal <>
Date: Mon, 23 Apr 2007 00:17:14 -0700

John Cowan wrote:
> That worked for CC because it was a greenfield situation: there were
> no open licenses for general content, and they could create a license
> templating system from scratch (although drawing on the FLOSS licenses
> to tell them what options made sense).  Such was not the case when the
> OSI was founded.  Attempting to replace the existing dominant licenses
> with new ones at this point would be quixotic.

True enough, but given a 30-year view rather than an immediate-future 
view, it's a really good idea. It may ultimately be the best path out of 
the compatibility mess. I've been saying this for a couple of years now, 
and in the past year have seen it popping up independently on multiple 
different blogs, which is a good sign that it's not only an idea that's 
right for the time, but one with a good chance of adoption. I'm not sure 
OSI is the right organization to do it, though.